A multi-stage tool for managing academic conference rebuttal feedback.
Install
mkdir -p .claude/skills/skills-runtsang && curl -L -o skill.zip "https://agentskills.codes/api/skills/download/13428" && unzip -o skill.zip -d .claude/skills/skills-runtsang && rm skill.zipInstalls to .claude/skills/skills-runtsang
Activation
This is the description your AI agent reads to decide when to run this skill — the better it matches your request, the more reliably it fires.
Multi-stage rebuttal analysis skill for RebuttalStudio. Use when organizing reviewer comments into stage-specific conference workflows, including stage1 breakdown, stage2 refinement, stage4 multi-round follow-up, and stage5 final remarks generation.Key capabilities
- →Organize reviewer comments into stage-specific conference workflows
- →Apply shared stage templates before conference overrides
- →Convert raw reviewer feedback into structured breakdowns for rebuttal drafting
- →Refine outline drafts into reviewer-facing rebuttal prose
- →Condense combined discussion into reusable markdown context
- →Fill final remarks template from all reviewers' condensed markdown context
How it works
This skill dispatches to specific stage workflows (stage1, stage2, stage4, stage5) and utility workflows based on the user's intent. It applies shared templates and conference-specific extensions to process reviewer comments and draft rebuttals.
Inputs & outputs
When to use skills
- →Breaking down reviewer comments
- →Drafting rebuttal prose
- →Refining conference responses
- →Condensing discussion threads
About this skill
RebuttalStudio Multi-Stage Skill
Follow this dispatcher structure:
- Identify stage first (
stage1,stage2,stage4, orstage5). - For
stage1andstage2, apply the stage template first, then select conference-specific extension. - Execute the conference skill instructions directly.
Available stage workflows
stage1/template/SKILL.md: Shared Stage 1 breakdown template. Apply before conference overrides.stage1/iclr/SKILL.md: Convert raw reviewer feedback into a structured breakdown for rebuttal drafting.stage1/icml/SKILL.md: Convert raw reviewer feedback into a structured breakdown for rebuttal drafting (ICML mapping).stage2/template/SKILL.md: Shared Stage 2 refine template. Apply before conference overrides.stage2/iclr/SKILL.md: Refine Stage2 outline drafts into reviewer-facing rebuttal prose.stage2/icml/SKILL.md: Refine Stage2 outline drafts into reviewer-facing rebuttal prose (ICML labeling).stage4/condense/SKILL.md: Condense Stage 3 combined discussion into reusable markdown context.stage4/refine/SKILL.md: Refine follow-up response using condensed context + follow-up question + user draft.stage5/final-remarks/SKILL.md: Fill Stage 5 final remarks template from all reviewers' condensed markdown context.
Available utility workflows
polish/SKILL.md: Polish (rephrase) a rebuttal message template for clarity and professionalism while preserving the original structure, tone, and intent.
Available stage-general utility skills
These skills apply across multiple stages and provide strategic, stylistic, and quality guidance:
utility/stage/review-response/SKILL.md: Comment classification (Major/Minor/Misunderstanding/Typo) and response strategy selection (Accept/Defend/Clarify/Experiment). Use when planning how to respond to any reviewer concern.utility/stage/writing-anti-ai/SKILL.md: Remove AI-generated writing patterns from rebuttal prose. Use after Stage 2 refinement or Stage 4 follow-up when text reads formulaic or robotic.utility/stage/text-condense/SKILL.md: Condense selected rebuttal prose into fewer words without changing meaning. Use when a paragraph is too long but the technical content should stay intact.utility/stage/rebuttal-self-review/SKILL.md: Pre-submission quality checklist covering coverage, tone, factual accuracy, structure, and clarity. Use after Stage 3 compilation or Stage 5 final remarks.utility/stage/citation-verification/SKILL.md: Verification workflow for any new citation added during rebuttal writing. Use when LLM-suggested references appear in Stage 2 drafts.
If a requested stage/conference does not exist, stop and ask for missing spec before inventing format. When adding a new conference for Stage 1 or Stage 2, extend the stage template and edit only conference-specific differences.
When not to use it
- →When the user's request does not involve multi-stage rebuttal analysis
- →When the specific conference or stage workflow is not available
- →When the user needs to generate content unrelated to reviewer comments or rebuttals
Limitations
- →Requires explicit stage identification (stage1, stage2, stage4, or stage5)
- →If a requested stage/conference does not exist, it will stop and ask for missing spec
- →Conference-specific differences are handled by extending stage templates
How it compares
This skill provides a structured, multi-stage approach to rebuttal analysis, applying specific templates and workflows for different conference stages, unlike a generic text editing or summarization tool.
Compared to similar skills
skills side by side with the closest alternatives in the catalog.
| Skill | Installs | Updated | Safety | Difficulty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| skills (this skill) | 0 | 4mo | No flags | Intermediate |
| book-scaffolding | 0 | 3mo | Review | Intermediate |
| prd | 0 | 4mo | No flags | Intermediate |
| speckit-specify | 0 | — | No flags | Intermediate |
Try saying
Example prompts that trigger this skill in your AI assistant.
More by runtsang
View all by runtsang →You might also like
book-scaffolding
NaveedTechLab
|
prd
alfredolopez80
Product Requirements Document generation and management with INVEST-compliant user stories
speckit-specify
MasterYXiao
Create or update feature specifications from natural-language requests for this Spec Kit workflow. Use when starting a new feature or re-baselining spec.md before clarify/plan.
maid-outcome-enrich
mamertofabian
Generate optional advisory Outcome enrichment outside maid-runner by orchestrating maid enrich prompt, agent-available model generation, maid enrich validate, and maid enrich render with cloud privacy disclosure.
docx
anthropics
Comprehensive document creation, editing, and analysis with support for tracked changes, comments, formatting preservation, and text extraction. When Claude needs to work with professional documents (.docx files) for: (1) Creating new documents, (2) Modifying or editing content, (3) Working with tracked changes, (4) Adding comments, or any other document tasks
docs-write
metabase
Write documentation following Metabase's conversational, clear, and user-focused style. Use when creating or editing documentation files (markdown, MDX, etc.).