Simulates journal peer-review with editor and referee feedback.
Install
mkdir -p .claude/skills/review-paper && curl -L -o skill.zip "https://agentskills.codes/api/skills/download/13043" && unzip -o skill.zip -d .claude/skills/review-paper && rm skill.zipInstalls to .claude/skills/review-paper
Activation
This is the description your AI agent reads to decide when to run this skill — the better it matches your request, the more reliably it fires.
Comprehensive manuscript review with three modes: single-pass (default), --adversarial critic-fixer loop, and --peer [journal] simulated peer-review pipeline (editor + 2 dispositioned referees + editorial decision, calibrated to a target journal). R&R continuation via --peer --r2/--r3; hostile-editor stress test via --peer --stress. Auto-invokes /review-r + /audit-reproducibility on referenced scripts unless --no-cross-artifact.Key capabilities
- →Locate and read the manuscript from various paths
- →Evaluate the manuscript across six dimensions
- →Generate 3-5 referee objections
- →Produce a complete review report
- →Save the report to `quality_reports/`
- →Simulate an editorial pipeline with editor and two blind referees
How it works
The skill reads the manuscript, evaluates it across six dimensions, generates referee objections, and produces a review report. It can also simulate a peer-review pipeline with different personas and dispositions.
Inputs & outputs
When to use review-paper
- →Simulate peer review
- →Stress test manuscript
- →Get referee feedback
About review-paper
Performs multi-mode manuscript reviews, including simulated peer-review pipelines with adversarial critic-fixer loops and journal-calibrated referee reports.
Comprehensive manuscript review with three modes: single-pass (default), --adversarial critic-fixer loop, and --peer [journal] simulated peer-review pipeline (editor + 2 dispositioned referees + editorial decision, calibrated to a target journal). R&R continuation via --peer --r2/--r3; hostile-edito
When not to use it
- →When the user already has referee comments and needs a response document
- →For lecture slides instead of papers
- →When the user needs seven independent lenses in parallel for review
Limitations
- →Hard cap at `--r3` for R&R continuation mode
- →WebSearch for novelty checks can return hallucinated citations
- →Does not automatically handle non-econ paper types in `methods-referee.md` without extension
How it compares
This workflow offers multiple review modes, including an adversarial critic-fixer loop and a simulated peer-review pipeline calibrated to specific journals, providing a more structured and complete assessment than a single, generic rev
Compared to similar skills
review-paper side by side with the closest alternatives in the catalog.
| Skill | Installs | Updated | Safety | Difficulty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| review-paper (this skill) | 0 | 3mo | No flags | Advanced |
| scientific-writing | 94 | 2mo | Review | Intermediate |
| content-research-writer | 15 | 10mo | No flags | Beginner |
| research-grants | 6 | 7mo | Review | Advanced |
Try saying
Example prompts that trigger this skill in your AI assistant.
More by xashgg
View all by xashgg →You might also like
scientific-writing
K-Dense-AI
Write scientific manuscripts. IMRAD structure, citations (APA/AMA/Vancouver), figures/tables, reporting guidelines (CONSORT/STROBE/PRISMA), abstracts, for research papers and journal submissions.
content-research-writer
ComposioHQ
Assists in writing high-quality content by conducting research, adding citations, improving hooks, iterating on outlines, and providing real-time feedback on each section. Transforms your writing process from solo effort to collaborative partnership.
research-grants
davila7
Write competitive research proposals for NSF, NIH, DOE, and DARPA. Agency-specific formatting, review criteria, budget preparation, broader impacts, significance statements, innovation narratives, and compliance with submission requirements.
clinical-decision-support
K-Dense-AI
Generate professional clinical decision support (CDS) documents for pharmaceutical and clinical research settings, including patient cohort analyses (biomarker-stratified with outcomes) and treatment recommendation reports (evidence-based guidelines with decision algorithms). Supports GRADE evidence grading, statistical analysis (hazard ratios, survival curves, waterfall plots), biomarker integration, and regulatory compliance. Outputs publication-ready LaTeX/PDF format optimized for drug development, clinical research, and evidence synthesis.
nsfc-research-foundation-writer
huangwb8
为 NSFC 正文"（三）研究基础"写作/重构，并同步编排"工作条件"和"研究风险应对"，用证据链证明项目可行、资源条件对位研究内容、风险预案可执行。适用于用户要写/改"研究基础、前期工作、可行性分析、工作条件、平台团队、风险应对"等场景。
arcanea-scene-craft
frankxai
Master scene construction - the building blocks of story. Openings that hook, middles that build, endings that propel. Turn every scene into a compelling unit of narrative.