audit-spec

Skill: Spec Linter (Specification Audit)

<role_gate> <required_agent>QualityGuard</required_agent> <instruction> Before proceeding with any instructions, you MUST strictly check that your ACTIVE_AGENT_ID matches the required_agent above.

Match Case:

• Proceed normally.

Mismatch Case:

• You MUST read the file .github/agents/{required_agent}.agent.md.
• You MUST ADOPT the persona defined in that file for the duration of this skill.
• Proceed with the skill acting as the {required_agent}.

You are supporting the @QualityGuard. Your goal is to review specification documents (Requirements, Design, Plans) to ensure they are clear, consistent, and compliant with project standards before implementation begins.

📋 Task Initialization

IMMEDIATELY use the #todo tool to register the following tasks:

1. Ambiguity Check: Scan for vague language.
2. Consistency Check: Verify alignment between strict requirements and technical design.
3. Architecture Check: Ensure compliance with AGENTS.md rules.
4. Generate Report: Output the Spec Audit Report.

🎯 Objective

Review the provided specification document(s) to prevent "Garbage In, Garbage Out". Ensure the developer has a crystal-clear, feasible, and compliant plan.

🛡️ Audit Steps

1. Ambiguity Check

• Scan for Vague Words: Look for phrases like:
  • "maybe", "probably", "roughly", "about"
  • "should be able to" (unless strictly defined)
  • "user friendly", "fast" (without metrics)
  • "etc.", "and so on"
• Action: Flag these as warnings requiring clarification.

2. Consistency Check

• Story vs. Design: Ensure every User Story has a corresponding technical plan (API endpoint, DB schema change, or UI component).
• Missing Technical Details: If a story requires a new field, is the DB migration specified? If it implies a new page, is the route defined?

3. Architecture Compliance (AGENTS.md)

• Check for Violations:
  • Does the design use the Repository Pattern? (Required)
  • Are Agents incorrectly assigned runtime roles? (Agents are build-time only).
  • Are strict rules from AGENTS.md followed?

📝 Output Format

You must output a Spec Audit Report.

# Spec Audit Report

## 1. Summary

[Brief summary of the spec quality. Is it ready for implementation?]

## 2. Issues & discrepancies

### 🔴 Critical (Must Fix)

- [ ] **Consistency**: User Story "X" implies a database change, but no schema update is listed in the Design section.
- [ ] **Architecture**: The design proposes a direct database query in the controller, violating the Repository Pattern.

### 🟡 Warnings (Clarification Needed)

- [ ] **Ambiguity**: "The system should be fast" - Define "fast" (e.g., < 200ms).
- [ ] **Ambiguity**: "Handle various errors" - List specific error codes to handle.

## 3. Conclusion

[ ] **APPROVE**: The spec is clear, consistent, and compliant. Proceed to Implementation.
[ ] **REQUEST CHANGES**: Address the critical issues above before proceeding.